I was reading an article in Reader’s Digest about the right ways to inspire your kids. This article talks about how parents sometimes say things that they think will help out their children. However, the kids tend to misinterpret the point their parents were trying to get across. One point this article made was how over praising kids can lead them to overestimated their abilities and cause them slack off. I agree with this; praise is a positive reinforcer, and when it is not abused, then it can prompt very positive behavior. This got me thinking about how Schumaker and Twenge have both talked about how narcissism is developed at a young age. One cause of this behavioral disorder is believed to be the self-esteem programs that are implemented in our schools. This article also points out that parents can also play a major role in this development. Saying things like “You’re the best!” to a child may seem harmless or even positively constructive, but research has shown that these phrases do more harm than help. There is nothing wrong with telling your children they have done well in school, sports, or musical performances. Yet, when you over praise them, it goes straight to their head. They thrive off the attention and start believing that they are superior to everyone. After all, they are the only ones that they know of receiving the praise.
How many times have you seen a young basketball player that has natural talent and is often praised by the coach and other parents? This praising can be overdone, especially after games, when everyone comes up after one another to congratulate the star player on how fantastic he was. If this is all he is hearing, then he begins to let it get to him. Next game, he might feel like he doesn’t have to try as hard to look like a superstar. Also, if he messes up, instead of practicing and trying to fix his weakness, he just thinks he can get away with it because he is the star. His teammates, on the other hand, will be better off in the long run. Though they are not in the spotlight, they strive and work hard to compete. They will continue to improve their skills and overall become better mechanical players. These players are often noticed when they do make a good play and not for their pure awesome studliness.
Our society believes that boosting a child’s self-esteem will set them up for a successful future. Unfortunately, as the previous example shows, too much praise can backfire. Showing approval of our kids is very important, but we must be careful of what we are approving of. When we focus on a kid’s score on a test and not the overall effort that went into achieving that score, we are essentially telling the kid that we are proud only when they when they have achieved the most. A study was done testing over praised fifth graders. The test scores of those students who had been constantly praised for trying hard triumphed over the test scores of those that had been praised for merely being smart. This shows that focusing on a kid’s effort instead of the end product actually serves to lead to a more successful future. A social psychologist, Carol _Dweke, remarked “Praising attributes or abilities makes a false promise that success will come to you because you have that trait, and it devalues effort.” Therefore, it’s important to recognize and praise your children’s effort, just know when to draw the line.
Subscribe to:
Post Comments (Atom)
4 comments:
Britty-
From what I can tell you are saying that basically praise in itself is positive, but it is the type of praise that matters, your welcome to correct me if I'm wrong (we both know I am a lot of the time!) The part about how kids that were praised for trying hard did better on a test than a kid who was praised for being me, made me think about how true it is. Especially, in my family my brother was always praised for being smart (AND WE KNOW HOW HE TURNED OUT) but then I was always praised for working hard because I was not naturally smart like my brother is. After middle school he just stopped trying because everything just came so easy to him but, I continued to work as hard as I could and earned the best grades I could. Maybe if we changed the way we praised the smarter ones they would achieve more? This is my big question for you because you are the hardest worker I know, did your parents praise you for your work habbits or for your natural intelligence???
Katy,
After thinking about your questions, I would assume that if we praised those who are naturally smart, like your brother, on their effort instead of what nature endowed them, then they will be more likely to push themselves into achieving more. Maybe your brother didn’t have to try as hard as you, but he still had to put some effort in. If parents are wanting to reinforce the importance of effort, then praising them when they demonstrate effort is key. Being naturally intelligent is not a behavior. The person can’t help it; it is just they way they are. Providing praise for just simply being who you are, doesn’t change anything. It just kid believe that they are awesome for doing nothing, and that they will never have to do anything but naturally be awesome. However, what they can change is how much effort they put into achieving a certain goal.
My parents focused more on my effort than my natural intelligence. They did tell me that certain things came easier to me than others, and that I should be thankful for that. However, they also stressed never to make fun of someone who has a harder time with a certain task. I believe because they stressed this, that I was put in a place where I didn’t feel superior because of my natural smarts. My parents always congratulated me on the As I received. They would say things like, “I know that it was hard work, and I am very proud of you”. At first I pushed myself to achieve high grades because I desired my parents approval. But eventually I didn’t need their reinforcement, and I just tried on my own. I believe this change in my motivation was partly because my parents never just told me “You are just so smart!”. They focused on the effort I put into it, which is probably part of the reason why I still try and put effort into things today.
I think that in your own original blogs, it is easy to see that you have a lot of good points to make on different issues. For example, in this blog, you have one main claim and a lot of reasons to support that claim which is good. It is what any good writer would do. However, a lot of your posts are in response to someone else's blog which I also think is very important. A lot of good writers use what they read to start their own piece of writing. One thing I would suggest to you is to blog more. The more you blog, the better your writing will be.
I think that this is a good post that you can use in your paper you bring up a very interesting issue that appeals to peoples senses. You also have showed that you have been reading, having sources cited. YOu do not just bring your personal opinion but you bring up others thoughts such as Twenge. Also your comments show that you hav brought up a controversial subject which is a good way to dtart conversation
Post a Comment